Bad Plants For Walstad Method Tanks! (There's Better Options For Your Dirted Planted Tanks)

Best Plants For Walstad Method Tanks -    • The Best Plants For Walstad Method Ta...  

TANK SETUP VIDEOS

Beginner-Friendly Betta Fish Tank -    • A Beginner-Friendly Betta Fish Tank S...  
Walstad Betta Fish Tank -    • Walstad Betta Fish Tank Setup + Month...  
Beginner-Friendly Guppy Tank -    • My Beginner-Friendly Planted Guppy Ta...  
Neon Tetra Tank -    • Easy Neon Tetra Community Tank Setup ...  
Walstad Cherry Shrimp Tank -    • Walstad Method Cherry Shrimp Tank Set...  
Walstad Shrimp Jar -    • Walstad Method Shrimp Jar Aquarium Se...  

Bad Plants For Walstad Method Tanks! (There's Better Options For Your Dirted Planted Tanks)

In this video, we delve into commonly recommended plants for Walstad method aquariums that might not be the best primary options for your planted tank. While these plants can serve as excellent secondary, decorative additions, they may struggle to naturally purify your water effectively. We'll discuss the characteristics and challenges of each plant to help you make informed decisions for your aquarium setup.

**Amazon Frogbit**: Amazon Frogbit is often recommended for aquariums due to its appealing appearance and ease of care. However, in Walstad method tanks, its extensive root growth can pose problems. The roots can penetrate the substrate, potentially causing issues with the tank's ecosystem. Although Amazon Frogbit can be managed with regular maintenance, it might be more practical to opt for alternatives like Salvinia or Red Root Floaters, which offer similar benefits without the root-related challenges.

**Bacopa**: Bacopa is a beautiful plant that adds a touch of elegance to any aquarium. Despite its aesthetic appeal, Bacopa grows too slowly to be effective as a primary filtration plant in Walstad method tanks. It can be a fantastic secondary plant, providing visual interest and some nutrient uptake, but it cannot compete with faster-growing plants in terms of water purification. For optimal results, Bacopa should be paired with more vigorous species.

**Ludwigia**: Ludwigia, particularly the mini super red variety, is known for its vibrant color and potential as a stem plant. However, many hobbyists, including myself, have encountered difficulties with its growth in Walstad method aquariums. Issues such as melting and inadequate lighting often hinder its success. While Ludwigia can thrive under specific conditions, it may not be the most reliable choice for Walstad tanks, especially for beginners.

**Java Fern**: Java Fern is a popular plant in the aquarium hobby due to its low maintenance requirements and hardy nature. Nevertheless, its slow growth rate makes it unsuitable as a primary water purifier in Walstad method tanks. While Java Fern can contribute to the tank's ecosystem, it should be used alongside faster-growing plants to ensure effective natural filtration.

**Bucephalandra**: Similar to Java Fern, Bucephalandra is appreciated for its unique appearance and resilience. However, its slow growth means it cannot absorb nutrients as quickly as needed for water purification. Bucephalandra is best used as a secondary plant, adding diversity and visual appeal to your aquarium without relying on it for primary filtration.

**Anubias**: Anubias is renowned for its hardiness and versatility in various aquarium setups. Although it can thrive in a Walstad method tank, its slow growth rate limits its effectiveness as a natural water purifier. Anubias should be considered a decorative plant rather than a primary filtration option. Its various types can enhance the aesthetic of your tank while other, faster-growing plants handle the bulk of nutrient uptake.

For a comprehensive guide on plants that excel as primary options in Walstad method aquariums, be sure to check out my other video linked in the description. I hope this information helps you avoid potential issues and achieve a thriving planted tank.

Thanks for watching, and have a great day!

TIMESTAMPS

00:00 - Intro
00:19 - Plant 1
02:19 - Plant 2
04:43 - Plant 3
06:47 - Plant 4
08:38 - Plant 5
10:01 - Plant 6

Some of the links in this video description may be affiliate links meaning I earn a small commission from any purchases made.