Originals Vs. Remakes: Phantom of the Opera (1925 vs. 1943)

The Phantom of the Opera has been adapted countless times for film, TV, radio and the stage. To compare and contrast all versions would be a monumental undertaking, so this video simply compares the two film adaptations that share the most DNA; the 1925 and 1943 films by Universal.


Both The Phantom of the Opera 1925 and Phantom of the Opera 1943 fall under the banner of the Universal Classic Monsters. The 1925 original is widely known for its famous and majestic sets, as well as for featuring the signature role for Silent Era icon Lon Chaney. The unmasking scene has gone down as one of the most famous scenes in all of film history.


The 1943 remake updated the story and took more liberties with the source material, in order to create a fresh and exciting take. Boasting dynamic camerawork and a great attention to detail in terms of art production and costuming, it is a delight to watch. It is also a less horror-focused take on the story, dwelling more on pathos, pity, comedy and romance.



But which is the best?

Chapters:
00:00 - Introduction
00:42 - Original (1925)
22:27 - Remake (1943)
38:11 - The Verdicts


Check out HauntedBlowfish on Twitter for more horror and film chat:   / hauntedblowfish  


Previous Originals Vs. Remakes:

Black Christmas (1974 vs. 2006 vs. 2019)
Castle Freak (1995 vs. 2020)
Wrong Turn (2003 vs. 2021)
Godzilla vs Kong (1962 vs. 2021)
Thirteen Ghosts (1960 vs. 2001)
Cabin Fever (2002 vs. 2016)
The Most Dangerous Game (1932 vs. 1945)
Slumber Party Massacre (1982 vs. 2021)
Death Wish (1974 vs. 2018)
Texas Chainsaw Massacre 2 (1986 vs. 2013 vs. 2022)

Firestarter (1984 vs. 2022)
Fu Manchu (1932 vs. 1965)