Mufti munir shakir vs Maulana Muhammad Ameer Bijligar | مفتی منیر شاکر قبر عذاب@Safi100
#muftimunirshakir #muftinadeem #maulanabijligar
Title: The Event of Ascension: A Debate Among Islamic Scholars
The scholars of Ahl al-Sunnah wal Jama'ah agree that the punishment of the grave is valid for the disbelievers and sinful Muslims, and this book is proven by Allah and the Sunnah of the Mutawatura, and no one denied it except some Mu'tazila etc. But the events of the time have shown that some people in this region of our sub-continent who are fond of the new light and who have grown up with Western civilization have adopted the religion of Mu'tazila, and they are deeply engaged in denying the punishment of the grave, so they are in this problem. There is a need to discuss in detail, first of all we present the arguments of the deniers of punishment and their answers, we will mention our own arguments.
Mufti Munir Shakir's Denial of the Event of Ascension:
Mufti Munir Shakir has taken a controversial stance by denying the event of Ascension altogether. He questions the authenticity of the narratives surrounding the Prophet Muhammad's journey and argues that the event is not mentioned in the Qur'an. According to Mufti Shakir, the belief in Ascension developed later in Islamic history and lacks sufficient evidence from the primary sources.
In support of his argument, Mufti Shakir emphasizes the importance of relying on the Qur'an as the primary source of Islamic teachings. He maintains that since the Ascension is not explicitly mentioned in the Qur'an, it cannot be considered an essential part of Islamic belief. He also points out that some of the hadiths narrating the event of Ascension have varying levels of reliability and can be subject to interpretation.
Maulana Muhammad Amir Bijlighar Sahib's Defense of the Event of Ascension:
On the other hand, Maulana Muhammad Amir Bijlighar Sahib, another respected Islamic scholar, firmly believes in the event of Ascension and considers it an established fact in Islamic tradition. He argues that the Qur'an and authentic hadiths provide sufficient evidence to support the occurrence of the miraculous journey.
Maulana Bijlighar Sahib highlights that although the Qur'an does not explicitly mention the event of Ascension, it alludes to it in Surah Al-Isra, where it mentions the night journey of the Prophet Muhammad. He argues that this indirect reference, coupled with the numerous authentic hadiths narrating the details of the Ascension, solidifies the event's validity.
Additionally, Maulana Bijlighar Sahib stresses the consensus among Islamic scholars throughout history regarding the event of Ascension. He argues that the scholarly consensus, known as ijma, carries considerable weight in Islamic jurisprudence and serves as a powerful proof for the event's authenticity.
Conclusion:
The event of Ascension remains a topic of discussion and debate among Islamic scholars, as exemplified by the contrasting viewpoints of Mufti Munir Shakir and Maulana Muhammad Amir Bijlighar Sahib. While Mufti Shakir denies the event's occurrence, focusing on the absence of explicit references in the Qur'an, Maulana Bijlighar Sahib firmly supports the event, basing his argument on the allusions in the Qur'an and the consensus of Islamic scholars.
Ultimately, individual scholars and believers are entitled to hold their own interpretations and viewpoints within the broader framework of Islamic faith. It is crucial to approach such debates with respect and scholarly inquiry, recognizing that diverse perspectives contribute to a more comprehensive understanding of Islamic teachings.
Mufti Munir Shakir Shaib
Mufti Nadeem Mahmoodi Sahib
Maulana Muhammad Ameer Bijligar Sahib
laila majnu pashto bayan,
laylatul qadr pashto bayan,
pashto bayan molana tariq,
pashto bayan molana bijligar,
pashto bayan muhammad idrees 2022,
pashto bayan mor aw plar,
pashto bayan maulana ihsan ullah haseen,
pashto bayan maulana abdul matin,
pashto bayan muhammad tariq,
pashto bayan maulana,
pashto bayan naat,
pashto bayan new 2022,
pashto bayan namaz,
pashto bayan nabi ali salam,
pashto bayan namaz ke bare mein,
pashto bayan na,
pashto bayan nikah,
pashto bayan new ramzan,
pashto bayan naachna,
pashto bayan nikah ao wada,
new pashto bayan,
new pashto bayan 2022,
pashto naat,
pashto naat 2022,
یہ میرے یوٹیوب چینل صافی ٹی وی کا لنک ہےمہربانی کرکے اس چینل کو ضرور سبسکرائب کیجئیے تاکہ میری نئی آنے والی ویڈیو آپ تک پہنچ سکے شکریہ
/ @safi100
Информация по комментариям в разработке