Скачать или смотреть کیا آغاجوادنقوی ایجنسیوں کےایجنٹ ہیں؟, تبرا، حضرت عمر اور آغا جواد,Mubashir Zaidi

🎙️ Guest: Agnostic Intellectual Mubashir Zaidi
🎙️ Host: Shamsuddin Hasan Shigri
🏛️ Organization: Council for Pluralistic Research and Dialogue
📺 Channel: Wahdat-e-Insaniyat
🎞️ Clip No. 6
Title & Key Discussion Points:
Main Question:
In pre-partition India, debates (munazaras) were frequent, and even excessive cursing (la‘n) didn’t cause major friction. But after the Iranian Revolution, a strong emphasis was placed on banning such practices altogether. How do you see this transformation?
Discussion Highlights:
• The practice of cursing (la‘n) the Caliphs in Shia Majalis and the later prohibition by contemporary Shia Maraji‘ (clerical authorities).
• The culture of Tabarra (reviling certain companions and caliphs) in Pakistan — its origin and impact.
• Why is it perceived that when a Sunni becomes an atheist or skeptic, they are no longer considered Sunni, but when a Shia becomes an atheist, their Shia identity is still culturally intact?
• Comparison between Iranian Shia atheists and Pakistani Sunni atheists — cultural and ideological similarities.
• Key differences between Sunni atheists and Shia atheists in terms of identity and mindset.
• Agha Jawad Naqvi — is he an intelligence agency operative?
• Have Shia scholars historically praised the first three caliphs? Agha Jawad Naqvi has delivered hours-long lectures on this subject — what’s the context?
• The issue of Jani Shah — a controversial figure or symbolic case?
• Hazrat Umar from Mubashir Zaidi’s perspective.
• The distinction between belief (Aqeedah) and culture — where does one end and the other begin?
1. Sunni vs Shia Atheists? Tabarra, Umar & Agency Allegations | Mubashir Zaidi | Clip 6
2. Cursing Caliphs, Cultural Shia Identity & Belief Divide | Mubashir Zaidi’s Critical View
1. سنی اور شیعہ ملحد میں فرق؟ تبرا، حضرت عمر اور آغا جواد کا کردار | مبشر زیدی | کلپ 6
2. عقیدہ یا ثقافت؟ تبرا، آغا جواد اور جانی شاہ کا مسئلہ | مبشر زیدی کی نظر میں
1. Sunni aur Shia Mulhid ka Farq? Tabarra, Umar aur Agency ka Ilzam | Mubashir Zaidi
2. Aqeedah ya Culture? Agha Jawad, Jani Shah aur Tareekhi Tanaazaat | Mubashir Zaidi

1. Sunni-Shia Mulhid Farq | تبرا اور کلچرل شناخت | Mubashir Zaidi | Clip 6
2. Tabarra, Sahaba & Shia Identity | مبشر زیدی کا تنقیدی تجزیہ | Jani Shah Debate
3. Umar ki Shakhsiat aur Tabarra ki Manaiyat | Siyasi ya Ilmi? | Mubashir Zaidi
Sunni-Shia Mulhid Farq Sunni vs Shia Atheists?, تبرا، حضرت عمر اور آغا جواد,Mubashir Zaidi

In this bold and wide-ranging discussion, agnostic intellectual Mubashir Zaidi reflects on sensitive issues within contemporary Shia discourse:
• What is the difference between a Sunni and a Shia atheist?
• Why does Tabarra (reviling the Caliphs) persist in Pakistan?
• How did the Iranian Revolution change the tone of Majalis and cursing practices?
• Is Agha Jawad Naqvi aligned with intelligence agencies?
• Has the praise of the first three Caliphs ever existed in Shia tradition?
• What’s the issue with Jani Shah?
• How does Mubashir Zaidi view Hazrat Umar today?
• What’s the line between belief and cultural identity?
🎙 Guest: Mubashir Zaidi
🎙 Host: Shamsuddin Hasan Shigri
📺 Channel: Wahdat-e-Insaniyat
🏛 Organization: Council for Pluralistic Research and Dialogue
اس فکری اور تنقیدی کلپ میں اگناسٹک دانشور مبشر زیدی ان سوالات پر گفتگو کرتے ہیں جو پاکستان کے مذہبی کلچر میں انتہائی حساس سمجھے جاتے ہیں:
• سنی اور شیعہ ملحد میں فرق کیا ہے؟
• تبرا اور خلفائے راشدین پر طعن و تشنیع کی روایت کا پس منظر کیا ہے؟
• انقلاب ایران کے بعد اس روایت میں کیا تبدیلی آئی؟
• آغا جواد نقوی پر ایجنسیوں سے وابستگی کا الزام کیوں لگتا ہے؟
• کیا شیعہ علما نے کبھی خلفائے ثلاثہ کی تعریف کی ہے؟
• جانی شاہ کا مسئلہ کیا ہے؟
• حضرت عمر کو مبشر زیدی آج کس نظر سے دیکھتے ہیں؟
• عقیدہ اور ثقافت میں فرق کیا ہے؟
🎙 مہمان: مبشر زیدی
🎙 میزبان: شمس الدین حسن شگری
📺 چینل: وحدتِ انسانیت
🏛 ادارہ: کونسل برائے تکثیری تحقیق و مکالمہ
Is gehri aur tahqiqi clip mein agnostic scholar Mubashir Zaidi kuch bohot nazuk aur aham sawalat par baat karte hain:
• Sunni aur Shia Mulhid mein asal farq kya hai?
• Pakistan mein Tabarra ka culture kyun barqarar hai?
• Iranian Inquilab ke baad Majalis ka lehja kaise badla?
• Kya Agha Jawad Naqvi agency ka agent hai?
• Kya pehle Shia ulema ne Khalifaon ki tareef ki hai?
• Jani Shah ka case kya hai?
• Hazrat Umar ko aaj Mubashir Zaidi kaise dekhte hain?
• Aqeedah aur Culture mein asal tafreeq kya hai?
🎙 Mehmaan: Mubashir Zaidi
🎙 Mehzban: Shamsuddin Hasan Shigri
📺 Channel: Wahdat-e-Insaniyat
🏛 Idara: Council for Pluralistic Research and Dialogue
• Guest: Mubashir Zaidi
• Host: Shamsuddin Hasan Shigri
• Channel: Wahdat-e-Insaniyat
• Organization: Council for Pluralistic Research and Dialogue
• Topics: Sunni vs Shia atheism, Tabarra, cursing Sahaba, Hazrat Umar, Agha Jawad Naqvi, Jani Shah, post-revolution Shia discourse, Shia cultural identi
#MubashirZaidi #ShamsuddinShigri #SunniAtheist #ShiaAtheist #Tabarra #HazratUmar #ShiaCulture #BeliefVsCulture #WahdatEInsaniyat #CouncilForPluralisticDialogue #JaniShah #AghaJawadNaqvi #ShiaSunniTensions