Episode 29: We Get Judgey

Welcome back to Episode 29 of The Commanders Pod! This week, we’re thrilled to have our special guest Andrew back for another round while Jeff is on vacation. Duncan and Sloan are diving deep into the world of Magic: The Gathering rules with our resident judge.



Today’s episode is all about unraveling the mysteries of the game’s most perplexing rules. We put Andrew’s extensive knowledge to the test with your most confounding questions:




• When multiple permanents owned by different players exile a card that would otherwise go to the graveyard, what’s the ruling?


• What’s the deal with phasing? Are phased-out permanents considered controlled? Do they exist for game purposes? Can their pips be counted for devotion?


• What’s one rule Andrew wishes players would understand better?


• And, is there a rule Andrew wishes Wizards would revise or eliminate entirely?




Tune in for an insightful and educational discussion that promises to clear up some of those tricky rules and give you a new perspective on the game. Whether you’re a seasoned player or just starting out, you won’t want to miss this deep dive into the rules that shape our beloved game.