From a Concerned Neighbor to a Sugar Mama

It’s a “Judge Mathis” throwback from 2019!

The plaintiff claims the defendant robbed her three times. She says some of her neighbors even identified the defendant as the thief, so she’s suing for stolen and damaged property. The defendant argues he never robbed the plaintiff. He says other neighbors started harassing him, including one who threatened him at gunpoint. He’s countersuing for emotional distress.

Now, the plaintiff is back for another case. But this time, she’s the defendant.

The plaintiff and defendant had a fling together even though the defendant is 20 years older. They eventually moved in together. He gave her his credit card to buy items for their home, but he claims she went on a shopping spree instead. He’s suing for a rental deposit, credit card charges, and harassment. The defendant claims the plaintiff is a liar. She’s countersuing for breach of contract and emotional distress.