Modern vs Vintage Turntables: Fluance RT85 vs Pioneer PL-115D

Can a 40+ year old turntable sound as good as a modern 2020's turntable?

This is NOT an attempt at a definitive test. I do not claim it to be anything other than a comparison between these two pieces of audio equipment. I also do not claim to be an "Audiophile". If I am, then it is only to the extent that my budget allows me to be.

Conditions of this Comparison:

Audio was recorded at the same levels using an external PCM recorder plugged directly into a Yamaha CR-420. Both RCA connects were input through the same PHONO stage in alternating order. The volume on the receiver remained the same. The cartridge and stylus were the same (Audio Technica AT-VM95ML) - both tracking at 1.75g. I considered using an acrylic "slip mat" on the Pioneer to even the playing field... but thought it would be more interesting to see how it performed as is with the original rubber.
Obviously, the RCA connects are not on the same playing field.

* A note on the cartridge used*
There has been some disapproval about the Fluance not having the Ortofon 2m Blue (which it sold with) fitted to it for the comparisons. The Audio Technica AT-VM95ML (micro line) was used for two reason. 1) Having several of the AT-VM carts, it is very easy to set up and calibrate overhang, etc. for each of the turntables (which are often not the same settings) and then simply remove the ML stylus from one, and use it on the other - making for an accurate, unbiased comparison. Again, this was done for easy... not to slight the 2m Blue. The 2m Blue is NOT as easy to calibrate and can be VERY picky in this regard. 2) The AT-VM95ML leans a light more toward the mid-range and has an affinity for reproducing vocals with more emphasis. Since "vintage" audio can at times leans a little toward a "warmer", or deeper, sound profile, I felt a mid-range cart would be more balanced than the "brighter" 2m Blue.

These are my reasons for my decision to opt for this choice in cart/stylus. No turntable (especially the Fluance RT-85) should have to stand on a singular cart choice to be recognized as good. If the turntable is worthy... it should be able to use a variety of cart/styli. Otherwise, it is handicapped.




Music: Bill Evan - Conception



#fluance #vintageaudio #Pioneer #turntable #vinyl #comparison