130 - Joe Rigney Responds to Ligon Duncan and the “Moscow Mood”

Support the show!! -   / chasedavis  

Full interview with Ligon Duncan on “Room for Nuance” -    • Thoughts on Theonomy & Christian Enga...  

Clip re: Moscow Mood -    • Mocking and Slander Is Not Going to F...  

“Leadership and Emotional Sabotage” - https://amzn.to/4avC7s0

Joe Rigney on Twitter -   / joe_rigney  

“Jesus Has AIDS” - https://www.russellmoore.com/2009/12/...

Summary

In this episode, Chase Davis and Joe Rigney discuss the interview with Ligon Duncan and the concept of the Moscow Mood. They explore the contrasting attitudes towards different opponents and the use of mockery and caricature. They also delve into the inner circle dynamics and the exclusionary nature of Big Eva. The conversation highlights the attraction to inner rings and the prevention of face-to-face interaction. They conclude by examining the motive behind the slapdown and the refusal to engage in meaningful conversation. The conversation explores the importance of inviting different voices and engaging with different perspectives, even if there is a lack of reciprocity. It highlights the dangers of dignifying every error and the need for clarity over nuance. The conversation also discusses the currency of credibility and the transition from a neutral to a negative world. It emphasizes the importance of courage and the recognition that leaders will make mistakes. Ultimately, the conversation encourages trust in the Lord and Jesus as the ultimate source of guidance.

Takeaways

Invite different voices and engage with different perspectives, even if there is a lack of reciprocity.
Be cautious of dignifying every error and focus on clarity rather than nuance.
Recognize the currency of credibility and the transition from a neutral to a negative world.
Have the courage to speak up and make mistakes, trusting in the Lord and Jesus as the ultimate source of guidance.

Chapters

00:00 Introduction and Background
01:00 Discussing Ligon Duncan and the Moscow Mood
03:47 The Use of Mockery and Caricature
06:09 The Irony of Criticizing Moscow Mood
07:11 The Inner Circle and Exclusion
09:21 The Duplicity of Big Eva
11:28 The Attraction to Inner Rings
21:12 The Evangelical Industrial Complex
25:17 The Inner Ring and Human Nature
28:24 The Motive Behind the Slapdown
34:35 Refusing Face-to-Face Conversation
35:18 Inviting Different Voices
36:08 The Lack of Reciprocity
36:59 Engaging with Different Perspectives
37:26 The Importance of Engagement
38:21 The Dangers of Dignifying Every Error
39:20 Paul's Response to Mistaken Identity
40:19 The Number of Times in Acts
41:16 The Mistaken Identity of Paul and the Apostles
41:45 The Currency of Credibility
45:08 The Inconsistency of Criticism
46:23 The Ritual Denunciation Strategy
48:23 Transitioning from Neutral to Negative World
49:48 The Incentive Structure of Ritual Denunciation
50:47 The Importance of Courage in Negative World
52:36 The Importance of Clarity over Nuance
54:31 The Apprehension of Trusting Leaders
57:10 Different Approaches Based on Community Context
59:05 Learning from Mistakes and Developing Faithfulness
01:03:48 Trust in the Lord and Jesus