Leica M4 vs M5: Ultimate Comparison of Classic Film Cameras – Features, Pros & Cons Explained

Leica M4 & M5 a radical change and a flop, but how the revolution made actually some sense after all

The Leica M4 and M5 are historically interesting models, each with unique features and user experiences. Let's start with the M4. Released between 1966 and 1975, it was intended to replace both the M2 and M3. One of the key improvements was the ability to see frame lines for four lens focal lengths: 35mm, 50mm, 90mm, and 135mm, essentially combining features of both the M2 and M3. Another upgrade was the double-articulated rewind lever, which made rewinding the film easier and more comfortable compared to earlier models, which required pulling a knob.

A major practical improvement was the internal mechanism for loading film. The M4 introduced a three-pronged system that made film loading faster and simpler. Aside from these, there were only minor cosmetic changes, and the user experience remained quite similar to the earlier models. The M4 also introduced the MDA, a version without a viewfinder designed for lab work or external reflex systems.

The M5, introduced in 1971 and discontinued by 1975, was a significant departure in terms of design and function. Its body was noticeably larger, which affected ergonomics, and it featured a rewind knob instead of a lever. Many of the internal mechanisms from the M4 were retained, like the three-arm system for loading film, but the overall experience was different. One major innovation was the built-in exposure metering system, developed in collaboration with Minolta. A sensor would retract when not in use but come into place when a lens was attached, allowing for in-viewfinder exposure readings.

However, this metering system had limitations. If you used collapsible lenses or certain older lenses, you risked damaging the sensor. The larger body and inability to use all previous accessories, such as motor drives, disappointed many users. These factors contributed to the M5’s lack of popularity, with only around 3,900 units produced. The M5 also had an unusual strap attachment system, with only two points on one side, which caused the camera to hang awkwardly. Later versions corrected this by adding a third attachment point for improved balance.

Despite its innovations, the M5 was considered a commercial failure, leading to its discontinuation in 1975. The M4, on the other hand, saw a revival in 1986 with the M4-P, which added frame lines for 28mm and 75mm lenses. The M6, released in 1984, was essentially an M4-P with through-the-lens (TTL) metering, and it became a classic. In summary, while the M5 introduced some groundbreaking features, it didn't resonate with all users due to its bulkier design and limited compatibility. The M4, with its more traditional design and reliable functionality, remained a favorite among many photographers.

want to support the channel ----
1 - subscribe to the channel, like and activate alert
2 - get the iOS apps https://appstoreconnect.apple.com/app...
3 - grab my books
Serial Matnum 2023 07 https://www.blurb.com/b/11665639
Serial Matnum 2023 06 https://www.blurb.com/b/11641364
3 - comment, respond, propose subjects for future episodes
yay! :)

direct links to playlists ----
http://aishit.net
http://voncam.net
fast links http://zand.li
http://zdrilx.com for the music