Mothers VS Black Magic! Which Aluminum polish works better?

Using a wheel polishing ball on a drill, I put Mothers up against Black Magic on my unfinished Aluminum Race Stars in order to find out which polish did its job better!

Elapsed time on each wheel was ~45m

Pro's and Con's;
Its hard to pick a winner between the two!
Black Magic didn't cut oxidation as well as the thicker and drier Mothers polish, but because the Black Magic was wetter it required less applications and used less product to get the wheel fully covered.
Its a long process and doing all four wheels in one sitting is a daunting project with the drill polishing ball, but because the Black Magic made it easier to apply i think overall knowing i'll save time i have to pick them!

Not sponsored by either of these brand!

Comment below which polish you think came out better!