Nancy Drew Ranked

After discussion within the Nancy Drew Community about which game is best, a project was started to uncover the truth. Here are the results!

Over 100 ND Community members ranked all 33 games on the following categories:
Atmosphere
Music
Puzzles
Mini-Games
Characters
Culprits
Plot/Story
End Game
Replayability
Overall Score
Nostalgia
**Mini-Games and Nostalgia scores were not included in the results of this video- a separate video will be made focusing on those two categories, as well as specific videos to show the ranking of each specific category that were covered in this video.

Those categories were ranked with the following system:
Superior- The best of the best games, extremely regarded
A-Tier- Excellent games, highly regarded
B-Tier- Great games, well regarded
C-Tier- Average games, fairly well regarded
D-Tier- Okay games, somewhat regarded
F-Tier- The weakest games

Those rankings were then converted to scores and were turned into overall percentages. Those percentages were what was used to determine the ranking of all 33 games.

The percentages were used to determine the following scores:
100-96% = Superior
95-90% = A-Tier
89-80% = B-Tier
79-70% = C-Tier
69-60% = D-Tier
59% and below = F-Tier

With over 100 responses, what resulted was a well rounded ranking list of all 33 Nancy Drew Games.

Huge thank you to the following discord channels for allowing the survey to be posted: V4H, NDWalkthroughs, and ND34 Caseboard. Additional thank you to Vote 4 Holt's YouTube channel for posting the link to spread the word!

So here it is! Sit back, relax, enjoy, and remember to stay sleuthy!

All rights belong to HerInteractive