Reb Beach-Dokken Solos (Live)

Reb from his brief stint with Dokken during a live concert in Anaheim, Ca. 11/4/99. I personally like his versions of the original solos, as he adds his own style to them instead of trying to recreate them note for note. If there are any Reb fans that haven't heard these, I think you're in for a real treat.

After many views and comments, with generally positive feedback (thanks!), I feel some perspective is needed here. There seems to be a "war" between who the better player is, Lynch or Reb. It really is a matter of opinion, but some facts need to be stated. Let's start with the originator of these solos, Lynch. Why is it that he's so revered in some circles? I am a huge fan myself, and the originality of his work is what sets him apart. His note selection and phrasing are unparalleled, period. To me, he sits at the top for creating solos that are instantly recognizable and memorable. As a kid starting out on guitar, he was my idol. With all that said, his inability to recreate his solos live is perplexing. I know many players like to take liberties when playing live and improvise all the time. However, I believe that is only partially true with Lynch. I don't think anyone can truly explain it. Just listen to all of his live performances. I certainly don't expect note for note recreations, but some of his solos are just awful live, and I really hate to say that.

Reb is an altogether different guitarist. While not on par with Lynch in composition, to not give him any credit is absurd on a grand scale. Sorry to burst some bubbles, but Reb has composed some great solos himself. Apparently there are many who are not familiar with Winger. If you feel the need to dismiss them, well you are clueless. These guys are all highly skilled musicians, whether you like their music or not. I respect bands for talent, even if I don't like their style, although I do like Winger. Ever listen to Madalaine, Headed for a heartbreak, Seventeen, or Miles away, just to name a few? Top notch solos indeed. Or how about Black Magic, which is a live take, no less. Now that is just a killer instrumental without a doubt. Where Reb gets the upper hand is his live performances. There cannot be any debate that he is the better live performer. Once again, just compare the two, and I'm not just talking Dokken songs. Anyone who is being honest with themselves has to agree.

So there you have it. As for me, I still like them both.