Do current trends make adaptations bad?

Hey yall, this is something that's been floating around my head for a while: how does the time period of an adaptation change the original work, especially when that work was created in a vastly different time period? Today we will look at many different adaptations - not just fantasy - to try and explore the question. Let me know your thoughts below!

Chapters
00:00 - The Lord of the Rings and The Rings of Power
03:31 - It's about themes, not aesthetics
05:53 - Reception vs longevity (Jane Austen, Lousia May Alcott)
13:26 - Fantasy adaptations are different
17:23 - A look at SFF adaptations (Dune, WoT, Harry Potter, Star Wars)
25:13 - Conclusion and universal themes

Socials
www.instagram.com/bookborn.reviews