Teaching Career REGRETS: Student Misbehavior & Apathy, No Creativity, Data Obsession, PLCs & LOW PAY

Why are so many 2nd career teachers quitting? In this eye opening episode of Teacher Therapy, we dive deep into the harsh realities Paul faced when he became a teacher in his forties. Paul was a former automotive manufacturing supervisor, Japanese language interpreter and college professor who transitioned into public school teaching, hoping to make a difference in the lives of young people. What he found instead was a system that felt more like a factory assembly line than a nurturing educational environment. Paul's journey is a striking example of the disillusionment that many second-career teachers experience when entering a profession that doesn't live up to its promise.

Paul shares his story, which begins with high hopes of fostering creativity, joy, and meaningful connections with students. However, he quickly discovered that teaching was plagued by many of the same issues he had left behind in the manufacturing world: extreme standardization, data obsession, and a rigid focus on cookie-cutter outcomes. The parallels between factory work and the modern classroom were impossible to ignore.

Some of the key challenges Paul faced as a teacher include:

Horrible student behavior and a lack of respect: Paul describes a classroom environment where students showed little interest or accountability for their own learning, while teachers were expected to shoulder the full responsibility for their futures.

Loss of autonomy and creativity: Paul recounts how his lessons were micromanaged, leaving him no room for creativity or personalization. Instead, hyper-standardized curricula and "quality control" systems were forced upon him, making teaching feel more like cranking out parts on an assembly line than nurturing young minds.

An obsession with data and standardized outcomes: In a shocking parallel to his previous career, Paul explains how schools now operate under systems eerily similar to the automotive world—focusing on data, standardized results, and constant assessment. The emphasis on numbers over students was both absurd and dehumanizing.

Professional development gimmicks and meaningless PLCs: Paul reflects on the countless hours spent in professional development sessions and forced collaborations that added nothing of value to his teaching but piled on additional busy work and stress.

Low pay, enormous workloads, and PLC committee leadership: Despite being underpaid, Paul was expected to lead PLC committees and take on leadership roles that further increased his already overwhelming workload.

Ultimately, Paul's experience, like many other second-career teachers, revealed the darker side of education: a system that stifles creativity, drains passion, and treats teachers like factory workers instead of professionals.

Join us as Paul opens up about the moment he decided to leave teaching and return to the automotive industry—a decision he doesn't regret—and hear his insights into where American education is falling behind. This episode is a must-watch for anyone who has ever felt trapped in a system that values conformity over individuality, and data over genuine learning.

#teachers
#firstyearteacher
#newteacher
#collegeprofessor
#historyteacher
#iquitteaching
#education
#teachertherapy
#educator
#educators
#classroom
#careerchange
#teacherlife
#teachershortage
#story