Hard vs. Soft Light: Clearing Up Common Misconceptions

Hard vs. Soft Light: Clearing Up Common Misconceptions

Hello everyone, Hugo here. Today, we’re diving into the basics of lighting—specifically, what makes light “hard” or “soft” and the misconceptions I’ve heard over the years, even from some experienced cinematographers. Whether it’s a bare bulb, an LED panel, or a softbox, understanding how light behaves is key to creating the look you want on screen.

What Exactly is Hard or Soft Light?

Let’s start with the essentials: hard light creates sharp, defined shadows, while soft light produces gentle, diffused shadows. But the type of light isn’t just about the source itself; it’s about the size of the light relative to the subject. The larger the light source relative to what it’s lighting, the softer it becomes. So if you’re wondering whether that small Aputure MC light or the 600D is soft or hard—it depends on how big the light appears to your subject and how close it is.

A Few Examples to Break it Down

Think about a bare bulb or a small LED panel. These are both small light sources and will generally create harder shadows because they’re compact. But if you take a whole bunch of those lights and put them side-by-side to make a big light wall, suddenly you’ve got a much softer light because the source has grown in size. Same goes for larger lights, like the ARRI S60 SkyPanel—if it’s close to your subject, it’s soft; if you move it 50 feet away, it acts as a hard light because it appears much smaller from that distance.

Misconception #1: Intensity Affects Softness

One of the biggest misconceptions I hear is that intensity affects whether light is hard or soft. It doesn’t. Increasing the brightness doesn’t change the quality of shadows. A light set at 10% or at 100% power will cast the same type of shadow. Brightness affects exposure, not the softness of light. So, if you want a softer look, focus on enlarging the light source or bringing it closer to the subject, not just cranking up the power.

Misconception #2: Diffusion Always Makes Light Softer

Here’s another misconception: that diffusion automatically makes light softer. The truth is, diffusion only softens light if it effectively enlarges the source. Let’s say you add a diffusion cover over an LED panel, but it’s the same size as the panel. This won’t make the light softer; it just spreads it out a bit and might reduce hotspots, but the shadows will still look the same. True diffusion happens when you’re enlarging the light source, like using a 4x4 or 8x8 frame with diffusion fabric on it, creating a larger, more spread-out source.

Real-World Application: Using Big Diffusion Frames on Set

On bigger sets, you’ll often see massive 12x12 or 20x20 frames with diffusion over them. These frames aren’t just there to look impressive—they’re creating a very large, soft light source. This allows cinematographers to place the diffusion farther away from the subject, which is useful for wide shots or for creating softer lighting that doesn’t look artificial or too close to the talent.

Hard Light and Soft Light in Practice

If you want a softer light, make the source larger or bring it closer to your subject. For hard light, keep the source small or farther away. And if you’re working with modifiers like softboxes or diffusion sheets, remember that the purpose is to make the light source appear larger from the subject’s perspective.

Final Takeaway: Big Lights Equal Soft Lights

At the end of the day, the key takeaway is that the size of the light source relative to the subject determines whether it’s soft or hard. Intensity, diffusion covers, or adding power won’t change that. So next time you’re on set, instead of thinking about just the type of light, consider how you can adjust its size and distance to get the look you’re after.

My Instagram: @hugo_willl

My website: www.hugowill.com

Gear I Use to Make Videos:
————————————————————
1. Canon C200 https://amzn.to/32CvH7w
2. Canon Eos R5 https://amzn.to/2Fb85kh
3. Sennheiser AVX-MKE2 https://amzn.to/3bJG4Mq
4. Sigma Art 18-35mm https://amzn.to/2obmxjG
5. Sigma Art 50mm https://amzn.to/2o5BGmp
6. Aputure 300x https://amzn.to/335idE3
7. Apple iMac 27 https://amzn.to/3604Jcj
8. G-Drive 16tb RAID https://amzn.to/2qBeixX
9. Arri Skypanel https://amzn.to/2Nb4hz5
10. Boom Mic https://amzn.to/2N7xmeP

My social media
————————————————————
Instagram:   / .  .
Facebook:   / hugowilldire.  .

Affiliate Disclosure:
————————————————————
Some of the links used in the description will direct you to Amazon, as an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases at no additional cost to you.