Umbrellas vs Softbox for soft light Portrait Photography for travel and portability

Umbrellas and softboxes are both used for video and portrait photography. Softboxes are usually clumsier and take longer to set up, while umbrellas are much lighter, more portable, less expensive and quicker to set up. Is there a visual difference in softness when going for a glamor look with off camera flash outside and in the studio? Let's find out!
items featured in this video:
Godox AD200 flash strobe
AD200 4,5" reflector and diffuserb AD-S2 https://www.adorama.com/fpbdmsl.html
Godox AD600 BM original flash strobe
AD600 7" reflector and diffuser https://www.adorama.com/fplfxp006k3.html
Glow Grand Box 32x32 softbox
Impact white translucent umbrella 43" https://amzn.to/3SIOklL
Westcott white collapsible umbrella 43" https://amzn.to/42R10vl
Westcott silver collapsible umbrella 43" https://amzn.to/42OUOE3
Promaster colllapsible silver umbrella 45" https://amzn.to/42MNOHW
Glow silver umbrella 40" https://www.adorama.com/glu40s.html
Cowboy Studio silver umbrella 43" https://www.amazon.com/CowboyStudio-4...
Soonpho 43" silver umbrella https://amzn.to/3uFSFhp
Glow windproof" umbrella 40" https://www.adorama.com/gluwp40.html
Interfit umbrella softbox 43"
Camera used Sony A7III with 55mm f1.8
Subscribe and tell your friends about MarkusPix.
Our Health channel is http://www.thehealthylife.com​
The Markus and Cara Instagram page is   / markusandcara​  
Cara's personal Instagram is   / iamcarabrotman​  
See photoshoot images of Cara at http://www.shortsillustrated.com​
Who am I    • Who am I