Скачать или смотреть Karen Ng, "Fanon and Hegel on the Recognition of Humanity"

Karen Ng, Vanderbilt University

Center for Global Ethics and Politics on February 6, 2024

Fanon and Hegel on the Recognition of Humanity

This paper defends an interpretation of Fanon's theory of recognition as revolving around his claim that we have a basic right to demand human behavior from the other. Developing key Hegelian ideas in a novel direction, I argue that Fanon's theory of recognition employs a concretely universal concept of humanity as a normative orientation for establishing what he
calls a "world of reciprocal recognitions," which he equates with the creation of a "human reality." In the first section, I take up the three passages from Hegel's Phenomenology of Spirit cited by Fanon in Black Skin, White Masks, to outline three key features of Fanon's theory of recognition. In section two, I argue that there are three senses of "universal humanity" operative in Fanon's work: a false universal, an abstract universal, and a concrete universal. Whereas the first two are critical, pejorative uses, the third provides the normative orientation for his account of recognition and social struggle. In the third section, I show how Fanon combines features of Hegel's concrete universal with features of Sartre's existential humanism in order to avoid an essentialist or ahistorical approach to human nature. Specifically, I argue that the ideas of self-transcendence and a universal human condition shed light on what Fanon refers to as the right of reciprocal recognition to demand human behavior from the other, and our one human duty to not renounce our freedom.