30% Tax On F&O | Will It Curb Retail Frenzy?

The debate over retail investors trading derivatives is heating up. From mandatory exams and increased margin requirements to stringent net worth evaluations, the debate has now pivoted to a potential 30% tax on derivatives transactions, similar to taxation on crypto.

These rules are meant to stop people from taking big risks and protect investors, but what they have done is ignite fierce debates about their actual effectiveness and the ripple effects they could unleash on market behaviour.

Before delving into whether a 30% measure will be effective, it's important to understand how the futures and options market functions.

F&O are financial contracts used in trading. A Future is an agreement to buy or sell an asset at a predetermined price on a specific future date.

Options, on the other hand, provide the right, but not the obligation, to buy or sell an asset at a set price before a certain date.

For example, if you think a stock's price will rise, you might buy a Call Option to lock in today's price for future purchases. Traders use F&O to speculate for profits or to hedge against potential losses, making these tools versatile in managing investment risks.

But is it really speculation though?

If you think an event will impact a stock's price, you need the know-how to understand whether the prices will go up or down.

So trading F&O is about skill, not just luck.

Consider this: suppose you closely follow the technology sector and anticipate that a company's earnings report will exceed market expectations, likely boosting its stock price.

With this insight, you strategically buy Call Options on the company's stock. This decision leverages your expertise in interpreting financial reports and market trends. If your prediction proves correct and the stock price rises, your Call Options could yield substantial profits.

In this way, F&O trading combines market knowledge, analysis, and strategic decision-making. It's a game of skill where informed predictions can lead to profitable outcomes, rather than relying solely on chance.

Another reason why people trade in F&O is to hedge their positions.

Hedging is a strategy to protect investments from market risk. In F&O, one can hedge a cash position by buying options contracts that offset potential losses.

For example, imagine you own stocks worth Rs10K and are concerned about a market downturn. By purchasing put options, you secure the right to sell your stocks at a specified price even if their market value drops. This strategy allows you to mitigate potential losses while still benefiting from any upward movement in the market. Essentially, hedging in F&O acts like insurance, safeguarding your investments from unforeseen market movements.

As you can see hedging is different from speculation as it focuses on minimizing downside risk rather than profiting from market fluctuations. It safeguards investments against adverse events, making it a prudent approach. Restrictions on hedging could intensify market volatility by exposing investors to greater uncertainty and risk.

Imposing a 30% tax on F&O would discourage hedging because distinguishing between speculation and hedging is practically impossible. Such a tax would likely deter investors from protecting their positions effectively, potentially leading to increased market volatility and more losses for the small guys.

And even if we logically can write off these arguments and say that the 30% tax will restrict people from dabbling in derivates, answer this - how many people actually make money in F&O?

As per Sebi's own admission, 9/10 traders incur losses in F&O.

So if the majority of traders in F&O are already experiencing losses, a 30% tax on F&O trades may indeed not deter new entrants or significantly reduce overall market participation.

This is because those who are already losing money might not be dissuaded from trading because of the tax itself, since losses are not taxed.

Therefore, the effectiveness of such a tax in curbing speculative activity or reducing market participation might be limited.

Instead, regulatory measures focusing on education, risk management, and transparency could potentially benefit traders more effectively in the long run.
..............................................................................................
News9 is India's first fully integrated English news brand across all digital platforms. It includes a publishing platform, viz. www.news9live.com, a future-ready OTT platform, News9 Plus, and a 24-Hour video streaming service on connected TVs and all social platforms.

► News9 Plus App : https://onelink.to/8pwfkc
► News9 OTT Coupons : https://bit.ly/4dwLDx4
► Watch us on YouTube :    / news9live  
► Like us on Facebook :   / news9live  
► Follow us on Instagram :   / news9live  
► Follow us on Twitter :   / news9tweets