Скачать или смотреть The Holy Spirit Defense: Why It Utterly Fails

Consider Supporting MindShift -   / mindshiftskeptic  
New Merch! - https://mindshift-shop.fourthwall.com

Video's Mentioned:
Context Video -    • When Christians Cry Context: A Closer Look...  
Labyrinth Video -    • The Labyrinth Isn’t What You Think  

In this episode of Comment Deep Dive, I revisit my video on biblical context - the one where I challenged Christians to provide a moral or coherent explanation for the Bible’s most disturbing verses. The featured comment claims that the true “context” isn’t historical, cultural, or textual at all, rather that it’s the Holy Spirit. According to this logic, unless you have the Spirit, you can’t understand Scripture.

Sub! → Turn on notifications for 3 new videos every week!
Connect! → Email - MindShiftSkeptic@gmail.com
Give! → Patreon -   / mindshiftskeptic  
📚Recommended Reading For Recent Deconverts (affiliate links): https://www.amazon.com/shop/mindshift...

Chapters:
0:00 Today's Comment
0:40 New Series Explanation
1:24 Summarizing My Context Video
2:59 Defining Terms
4:08 Unfalsifiability and Circularity
5:06 Consistency
7:16 Understanding vs Justifying
9:07 Personal Experience
10:18 Lacking Answers
12:33 Ending Breakdown
15:44 Final Thoughts
16:38 Patron Thanks

Iconoclast Tier
Anne Stephens
Boris Selioutsky
Chris
Grant
GVI Precision Body & Paint
Jimmy Tux
Joe Evilsizor
Kitboga
Matthew Kuplack
Perry Criagh Harrison
Shawn Skaggs

Humanist Hero Tier
Chris
Chris
Craig Harrison
James Geider
Jarrod Nichols
Kristi Goff

Atheist Advocate Tier
Aquitar
Caleb Taratuta
Claeb JK
Dakota Beeson
Dan Carter
Drew Smith
Jeff Watkins
Jeffrey Bell
Jeremy Green
Jugs
Julie H
Malcom
Paul Henry
Sparky
Thomas Elliott

Secular Scholar Tier
Agathon Zigglar
AJ
Alan Beshersee
Austin Smith
Ben Peterson
D. Cox
Ed
Elizabeth Duran
Fernando Dos Santos
Grant Lee Edwards
Jeff Day
Josh King
Kathy N
L
Maggie
Mark
Mark Rogers
Matthew Norquist
Melissa Little
Michael Martin
Pamela Polcover
Ray Calabro
Rokkit Serjun
Scottt
Simonsis 13
Snoop Squeak
Steve Boyer
Todd Hill
Trader J Rae
Vince

Freethinker Tier
Arthur Prindle
Autumn
BeccaYoley
Beegee
Ben Songster
Blake
Carol Ames
Carole Parks
Charles Payet
Charlotte Wayne
Chris Bennett
Christina Simmers
Danny Ferrell
Darque Syde of D'Lyte Productions
David T
Deanna Dandrea
Debbie Andrews
Douglas Nichols
Edvard Majakari
ElGuapo
Eric Sage
Eric Winston
Erika
Everton Shaw
Frank Saunders
Fredrik Sanfridsson
G Mark Wenner
Gerry Novak
Gregory Smith
hats Optional
Helen Carter
Jacki Berggren
Jacquie4678
James Musson
Janet Clark
Jay Nichols
Jeff Miles
Jenniewb
Jennifer leibig
Jerry O Connor
John Battaka
John Gilchrist
John Rexrode
Journey
Justin Jordan
Kami Rose
Konrad P Kummli
Lisa Reshad
LouCee
M
Mark Childers
Mark McKeen
Miguel Henriques
Newtwen
Orion H
Paul M. Palmer
Penelope
Peter Kang
Phil Mauriala
Pil Kang
Rick Landsman
Robert Dagit
Ron Warzek
Russ Andrews
Sally Dunn
Scott Graham
The Merlin
Tim Schanz
Tom Long
Tyler Harrell
Vorcha2911
Wanderer
Wearloga
William Spray
Yattwood
Zach Burns

Skeptic Tier
A B
Adam Cameron
Alais Joie
Alex
Andrew W
Angelo Gordon
Aprelle Neal
April Wilson
Austin Shaw
Bill
Brandon Eloy
Brandon Michaels
Breann Clark
Bright Argyle
Carah Monroe
Carla Crandall
Cheryl
Chrissy France
Christian
Christian Adams
Christian yearwood
Cole
Critical Explorer
Dan sprankle
Dangerman-1973
Daniel LeBoeuf
Darlene Esteban
Dave Lindop
David Deboy
David Legare
David Melton
David Modica
David Newcomer
Dennis Kimble
Donald Shellman-Kuhns
Dormouse
Doug From Brazil
Doug Wulf
Drew
Drew Gross
Eileen Gruber
Elijah Jeffery
Els Kraakman
Elvis Manson
emily evans
Explodington
Ezekiel Hansen
Fuad Harahap
Fatima Ferreira
Gary Burt
George Brush
GingerBeard
GnosticallyIntruiged
Grant Urben
Ian Kirkpatrick
Isabel Oliveira
Izzy
Jackson Stacy
Jadin Verduzco
Jake
James Rivard
Jason Otero
Jason Rollins
Jed Wentz
Jeff Watkins
Jeg 803
Jeremy Keane
Jeremy Shepherd
Jessica Drake
jimothyjones
Jon U
Jonathan Cox
Joseph Collins
Josh Nerney
Josh Powers
Joshua Ates
Joshua Newsted
Jude Saunders
Jukkari
Katherine Rabia
Kid Charlamagne
LadyVirgilia
Larry Ferrar
larry James
ledhed68
LeoG
Lisa
Lori Wieser
Louise
Lowen Starling
Lynn Kaiser
Margery Cavins
Marilynn Petit
Mark Bodzislaw
Mark Rothenbuhler
Martin
Matthew Baird
Matthew Mack
MattySouthPaw
Michael Maximé Yves Foy
Michael Solis
Michele
mks mks
Nate Dogg 1999
Nathan Sutton
Naveen
nicholas deamons
OminousCalm
Pablo
Paul G
Pippin Lowe
Procrastination
Pumpkin Jay
Raelie
Randy Scott
Ravyn
Ray
Richard Wigton
Robert C.
Robert Zoro
roland joseph watts
Ron Hott
Ron Mortenson
Ryan Phipps
sco
SCOTT KERNS
scvanderhorst
Serban Marcu
Sheila J
Shmeels
Simon D
StarryNight
Stephanie Campbell
Stephanie Ng
Stephen Branom
Steve Williams
Suicune2000
Susan
Susanna Billingham
Terri Johnston
Terry Menta
TG Yeo
TheDoremouse
Tim Morrow
Tina PVhouse
Tom
Tony F
Tony Maitland
Tristan
Tyler Perrenoud
Valerie hendrick
Wade
William Totherow
William Yalen

#atheist #mindshift #atheism