C64 vs Atari ST / Music Comparison

Recently, I posted a Atari ST Video here and got a reply from someone saying, that he "hates the St Soundchip" and "The C64 SID chip was better". I had a C64 myself and know of course that the SID Chip was indeed great. But Is the difference really that big as much people think? Here a direct comparison between 15 game tunes each in c64 and Atari ST Version. Judge yourself!

00:00 Speedbal C64
00:31 Speedball Atari ST
01:02 Platoon C64
01:43 Platoon Atari ST
02:23 Thundercats C64
03:11 Thundercats Atari ST
03:59 IK+ C64
04:39 IK+ Atari ST
05:23 Xenon C64
06:18 Xenon Atari ST
07:13 Gianna Sisters C64
08:02 Gianna Sisters Atari ST
08:52 Chambers of Shaolin C64
10:32 Chambers of Shaolin Atari ST
12:12 R-Type C64
12:51 R-Type Atari ST
13:13 Defender of the Crown C64
14:25 Defender of the Crown Atari ST
15:26 Spherical C64
16:34 Spherical Atari ST
17:42 Cybernoid2 C64
18:43 Cybernoid2 Atari ST
19:45 Stormlord C64
21:51 Stormlord Atari ST
23:59 Barbarian C64
25:50 Barbarian Atari ST
27:41 Grand Monster Slam C64
29:04 Grand Monster Slam Atari ST
30:27 Beyond the Ice Palace C64
31:50 Beyond the Ice Palace Atari ST