Chapter 11 of Building Thinking Classrooms Deep Dive Discussion

Get the book here -- https://amzn.to/3UN7qsH (affiliate link)

📝 How Students Take Notes in a Thinking Classroom: FAQ 📝
🤔 1. What is the issue with traditional note-taking in math classrooms? 🤔
The traditional "I-write-you-write" note-taking method, where students copy notes from the board, is often a mindless activity. Students struggle to keep up with the teacher, resulting in incomplete or inaccurate notes. This process hinders understanding and becomes an exercise in transcription rather than thinking.

📖 2. Why is traditional note-taking considered a mindless activity? 📖
Copying notes verbatim doesn't engage students in critical thinking or making connections between concepts. The non-linear nature of math problem-solving clashes with the linear way notes are often presented, forcing students to prioritize writing over understanding.

🌟 3. What are the benefits of encouraging "thinking" notes? 🌟
Thinking notes encourage students to process information, make connections, and personalize their understanding. By focusing on key ideas and examples, students create notes that are meaningful and useful for future reference.

✍️ 4. How can teachers encourage students to take meaningful notes? ✍️
Teachers can encourage meaningful notes by:

Shifting the purpose: Frame note-taking as a way to remember important information for their future selves, not just for the next test.
Providing structure: Introduce graphic organizers to help students organize their thoughts and identify key ideas.
Emphasizing student choice: Allow students to decide what information is essential to record and how to represent it.
Using think-pair-share: Have students compare notes and discuss their choices, promoting collaborative learning.
📋 5. What are the three key competencies students need for effective note-taking? 📋
Creation: Producing a worked example.
Annotation: Using small phrases and side examples as signposts on the journey through a worked example.
Selection: Choosing an appropriate worked example to form the basis of a question.
🗂️ 6. How can graphic organizers support note-taking? 🗂️
Graphic organizers provide a visual structure for note-taking, helping students categorize information, highlight relationships between concepts, and create a more meaningful representation of their understanding.

🎒 7. Are meaningful notes only relevant for higher grades? 🎒
No, meaningful notes are relevant for all grades. Even young students can benefit from taking notes that help them make sense of new information. The type and complexity of notes may vary depending on age and subject matter.

💡 8. Is there a better alternative to traditional note-taking altogether? 💡
While technology offers platforms for sharing notes online, the act of writing itself has cognitive benefits. Meaningful note-taking encourages active processing and personalized understanding. The key is to shift away from mindless copying towards notes that serve as a tool for thinking and future reference.